How it compares
This page compares the build with SeedSigner, a popular DIY signer, and Blockstream Jade, a commercial one, from a beginner builder’s point of view: what it costs and where you get the parts, what you learn by building it, and how secure and mature it is. It isn’t a ranking. Both are far more mature than this prototype.
| Project | Price, and where to get the parts | What you learn by building | Security and maturity |
|---|---|---|---|
| This projectThis build | About $42 for everything, or about $41 for the four boards: what the builder paid in Kenya, converted from shillings. The ESP32 DevKit, ESP32-CAM, Uno-style 2.8" touch shield and USB-TTL adapter are common hobby parts sold by local electronics shops, and you may already own some of them.[1] | A 12-step guide that explains each part as you go. You wire three boards together with jumper wires, patch two libraries, flash two microcontrollers, and see each step of how a transaction is checked and signed.[2] | A prototype for signet (a test network) only. Both boards have radios, which the firmware never uses. No secure element and no secure boot yet.[3] |
| SeedSignerDIY | Its README says the parts are "usually < $50": a Raspberry Pi Zero (version 1.3 preferred), a Waveshare 1.3" 240×240 LCD and a Pi Zero-compatible camera.[4] | You put together a Pi Zero, a screen and a camera (you may need to solder the header pins), then write a ready-made, verified image to a microSD card.[4] | Stateless (memory is wiped when power is removed). Supports mainnet, testnet and regtest. Release images are reproducible since v0.7.0. Recommends the Pi Zero 1.3, which has no Wi-Fi or Bluetooth.[4] |
| Blockstream JadeCommercial | On the Blockstream store, the regular price of Jade is $79.00 USD. Jade Plus is sold only in bundles, such as Jade Plus with JadeLink at a regular price of $189.00 USD.[5] | A ready-made device, so there is nothing to build. You learn by using it.[5] | A commercial product. Jade Plus "saves your encrypted wallet data to the device" and unlocks it with a 6-digit PIN, or you can skip the PIN and scan a SeedQR each time.[6] |
Sources for the table
- Firmware docs:
parts.yaml (the builder's prices); plan.md §1.1, checked on 2026-11-17 - Firmware docs:
docs/wiring.md; docs/patches.md; plan.md §7, checked on 2026-11-17 - Firmware docs:
plan.md §1, §1.2; docs/blog/comparison.md "Where others are ahead", checked on 2026-11-16 - github.com/SeedSigner/seedsigner, checked on 2026-11-17
- store.blockstream.com/jade, checked on 2026-11-17
- help.blockstream.com/blockstream-jade/use-jade-air-gapped/air-gapped-jade-plus-setup, checked on 2026-11-16
Where this build stands out
Section titled “Where this build stands out”- Price, with parts you can buy locally. All the parts cost about $42, the builder’s own shop prices in Kenya. That’s below SeedSigner’s own estimate of “usually < $50”, which needs a specific Raspberry Pi Zero, screen and camera, and about half of Jade’s $79 regular price. The boards are common hobby parts, so you may already own some of them. Prices vary by country and shop, so check your own.
- Learning by building. The build guide takes you through 12 steps and explains each one: the wiring, the library patches, flashing two boards, and how a transaction is checked and signed. SeedSigner is assembled from a few parts and then runs a ready-made image. Jade is bought ready to use. Both are better choices if you want a wallet to use; this build is for learning how one works.
What this project does differently
Section titled “What this project does differently”These are design choices, not claims to be the best.
- A physically one-way camera wire. The camera is a separate board joined to the signer by a single wire that only carries data towards the signer. SeedSigner’s camera plugs straight into the Pi Zero, and Jade’s camera is built into the device. I didn’t find another signer built this way, but that doesn’t prove there isn’t one. Its limit: the camera board still sees everything it scans, including a SeedQR, and its chip has a radio.
- A strict rule for spending more than one coin. With more than one input, the device refuses unless it has the earlier transactions that created each coin, which addresses the fee attack known as CVE-2020-14199. That is stricter than SeedSigner and, as far as could be traced, Jade. The cost is real: in testing, Sparrow’s QR codes didn’t carry that data, so a multi-input spend needed Sparrow’s saved file and an extra tool on the computer. SeedSigner’s documentation explains why it chose otherwise: the warning would fire on almost every ordinary multi-input spend. It’s a trade-off, not simply better.
- Signing a rebuilt transaction that holds only verified values. The device never gives the scanned data to its Bitcoin library. It builds a fresh, minimal PSBT from the values it has checked and signs that (see How it works). Whether other signers do something similar wasn’t checked, so this isn’t claimed to be unique.
Not new, and not claimed: stateless seeds, QR-only data, SeedQR, change verification, review screens, sighash checks, and building from cheap parts are all established ideas, and projects like SeedSigner and Jade were the references for this one. An ESP32 signer isn’t new either: Jade uses one, and an ESP32 port of SeedSigner is in progress.
Where others are ahead
Section titled “Where others are ahead”From the project’s comparison notes, read from each project’s own pages on 2026-11-02. The points about mainnet, reproducible builds and the Pi Zero 1.3 were confirmed again on 2026-11-17.
- Real use. SeedSigner supports mainnet, and Jade is a wallet for real funds. This build is signet-only.
- More address types and multisig. SeedSigner supports multisig, and more script types than this build’s single native SegWit type.
- Verifiable software. SeedSigner’s release images are reproducible, so anyone can check that a download matches the published code.
- Hardware choices. SeedSigner recommends a Raspberry Pi Zero 1.3, which has no Wi-Fi or Bluetooth at all. This build’s boards have radios that are only switched off in software.
- A finished product. Jade is a finished commercial device. This build is boards and jumper wires, and has no secure boot yet: it’s only researched in Phase 9.
- Maturity. Both have been used and reviewed far longer.
The Roadmap shows what this project plans next.